What Counts as Evidence in Linguistics: The Case of Innateness
What counts as evidence in linguistics? This question is addressed by the contributions to the present volume (originally published as a Special Issue of Studies in Language 28:3 (2004). Focusing on the innateness debate, what is illustrated is how formal and functional approaches to linguistics have different perspectives on linguistic evidence. While special emphasis is paid to the status of typological evidence and universals for the construction of Universal Grammar (UG), this volume also highlights more general issues such as the roles of (non)-standard language and historical evidence. To address the overall topic, the following three guiding questions are raised: What type of evidence can be used for innateness claims (or UG)?; What is the content of such innate features (or UG)?; and, How can UG be used as a theory guiding empirical research? A combination of articles and peer commentaries yields a lively discussion between leading representatives of formal and functional approaches.
Was andere dazu sagen - Rezension schreiben
Es wurden keine Rezensionen gefunden.
Typological evidence and Universal Grammar
Remarks on the relation between language typology and Universal
What kind of evidence could refute the UG hypothesis? Commentary
Is there any evidence that refutes the
Remarks on Weißs
Commentary on Eckman
Commentary on Fischer
Andere Ausgaben - Alle anzeigen
acquired allow approach argue argument assumed basis brain Cambridge child Chomsky claim cognitive competence consider constraints constructions determined direct discussion distinction empirical English evidence evolution example exist explanation explanatory fact factors formal functional further German given grammar head historical linguistics human hypothesis important innate input instance interesting issue John kind Kirby knowledge language acquisition learner learning linguistic typology markedness marking means nature negative Newmeyer Note notion noun object observed parameters particular patterns position possible predicate Press principles problem pronouns properties proposed question reason refer relative clauses relevant respect result role rules seems sense simply speakers specific speech standard structure suggests syntactic syntax theoretical theory tion typological understanding Universal Grammar universals utterances variation verbs volume Weiß