 | American Political Science Association. Annual Meeting - 1910 - 204 Seiten
...the judgment and discretion of the head of a department, his decision thereon is conclusive; and that even upon mixed questions of law and fact, or of law...correctness and the courts will not ordinarily review it, though they may have the power and will occasionally exercise the right of so doing.'" This rule would... | |
 | Westel Woodbury Willoughby - 1910 - 804 Seiten
...strong presumption of its correctness, and the courts will not ordinarily review it, although they have the power, and will occasionally exercise the right of so doing." In Marquez v. Frisbie38 the court declare that " it is a sound .principle that where there is a mixed... | |
 | 1911 - 792 Seiten
...the judgment and discretion of the head of a department, his decision thereon is conclusive; and that even upon mixed questions of law and fact, or of law...will occasionally exercise the right of so doing." But these questions need not be determined. If complainant has a cause of action for the excess payments... | |
 | Ernst Freund - 1911 - 726 Seiten
...the judgment and discretion of the head of a department, his decision thereon is conclusive; and that even upon mixed questions of law and fact, or of law...will occasionally exercise the right of so doing. Upon this principle, and because we thought the question involved one of law rather than of fact, and... | |
 | Ernst Freund - 1911 - 716 Seiten
...questions of law_and__fact, or of law alone, his ^tinn_wj]ljgrry_\iYith it a_ strong presumption of_its correctness, and the courts will not ordinarily review...will occasionally exercise the right of so doing. Upon this principle, and because we thought the question involved one of law rather than of fact, and... | |
 | United States. Solicitor of the Dept. of Commerce and Labor - 1912 - 662 Seiten
...department, his decision thereon if' conclusive: and that even upon mixed questions of law and fact, or law alone, his action will carry with it a strong...review it, although they may have the power and will "ccasionally exercise the right of so doing. This claim has been approved for payment by the Secretary... | |
 | United States. Office of Commissioner of Internal Revenue - 1914 - 326 Seiten
...the judgment and discretion of the head of a department his decision thereon is conclusive; and that even upon mixed questio'ns of law and fact, or of...although they may have the power, and will occasionally exorcise the right of so doing. In Public Clearing House v. Coyne (194 US, 497) the court held, in... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1914 - 726 Seiten
...the judgment and discretion of the head of a department, his decision thereon is conclusive; and that even upon mixed questions of law and fact, or of la'w...with it a strong presumption of its correctness, and MR. JUSTICE HARLAN and The CHIEF JUSTICE, dissenting. 194 US the courts will not ordinarily review... | |
 | Curtis Holbrook Lindley - 1914 - 968 Seiten
...judgment and discretion of the head of a department, his decision thereon is conclusive ; and that even upon mixed questions of law and fact or of law alone, his action will carry with it the strong presumption of its correctness, and the courts will not ordinarily review it, although they... | |
| |
The rule upon this subject may be summarized as follows: That where the decision of questions of fact is committed by Congress to the judgment and discretion of the head of a department, his decision thereon is conclusive; and that even upon mixed questions... 
